There is a raging debate globally on not just the future of Manchester United but also the present and the past which makes for a very interesting discussion. Whenever I do read an article online on this topic, I tend to agree, even if the point of views shared are in conflict.
Lets start by getting the known facts out of the way - Yes, Manchester United's playing style isn't mesmerising - Yes, Rooney has not been playing like he used to a decade ago - Yes, Paul Scholes does have a point.
Van Gaal was brought in to bring back the glory days of Manchester United. Credit to him, he has stuck to the task. I do not have much visibility into his contract unfortunately but I can assume it does not read "Make x% less sideways passes" or "$y for every shot on goal". It probably reads something in the likes of "win the title" or "secure Champions league qualification" or something similar.
The point is - Van Gaal has his own version of bringing the glory days back to United in the form of silverware - the fans had something else in mind. Its worth noting that Manchester United's football style is what brought fans to the club's fanbase in the first place and its nothing short of torture sometimes the way the build up play works these days. Admittedly, Van Gaal is probably better equipped to decide than the fans and probably having a resolute defensive setup is what is required to build on. The fans need to understand the attack-attack-attack style of Sir Alex Ferguson was a facet of the previous era which has passed. Maybe the way forward is a new strategy to rebuild defensively and later, when the time is right, switch on that 'offensive' button. One thing for certain, if United finish as Champions, everyone will forget the drab displays and automatically feel we have made a huge step towards bringing back the glory days.
Wayne Rooney is a legend at the club. He has done plenty.
If someone questions his captaincy, they do not know what they are talking about. After Roy Keane, Rooney has been the definitive United player - fighting for his team, scoring goals, winning matches and also having the commitment to run back 80 yards to complete a tackle when required.
Needless to say, his performances this season has been lacklustre.
In my opinion, Rooney is facing what a footballer normally faces at 34 - a decline in pace, agility & deadliness. People will say he is only 30, he should have at least 3-4 years to go. I would argue Rooney started as a 16 year old whereas other usually start at 20. The decline is normal.
The idea now is to find his right position where he can play with relative ease and take an extra touch if required. For example, Bastian Schweinsteiger's role allows for him to be able to not have to take immediate action with the ball every single time he gets the ball with players pressing. At his stage, his presence is sustainable. If you expect Rooney to do what he did a decade ago, that won't happen. It up to Van Gaal to find that right position which will be able to make the most of his remaining playing career.
Here's to more banter, conflicting views and glory days!